'Water is just water' — Mineral water comparison: Eira vs. Monviso Canvas
All you need is a glass of water, a pan and a little heat. That’s all it takes to demonstrate that not all mineral water is the same.

'There's no difference between waters.'
You hear this all the time. After all, water looks like water — it’s clear and transparent, and it's difficult to tell the difference between them at first glance.
But is that really true?
I wanted to find out for sure, so I compared two mineral waters: Eira Sparkling from Norway, with a total mineral content of 36 mg per litre (TDS); and Monviso Canvas Still from Italy, with a total mineral content of 433 mg per litre.
The experiment was incredibly simple.
The experiment: Two different waters, one pan, and a water comparison
I poured a small amount of each water into a clean pan and left it to evaporate completely.

EIRA – total dissolved solids: 36 mg per litre
After the water had evaporated, hardly any residue remained in the pan. There were almost no visible deposits or residues. This result is consistent with EIRA's very low mineral content.

MonViso Canvas – total dissolved solids: 433 mg per litre
A completely different picture emerged here: After evaporation, a clearly visible, whitish residue was left in the pan. The mineral components had become visible as deposits. The pan was significantly whiter than after the EIRA test.
What had previously been dissolved in the water and invisible became visible as a result of evaporation. The difference is now visible even to the bare eye.
What does “Total Dissolved Solids” actually mean?
It refers to the total amount of substances dissolved in water. These substances are primarily minerals and salts. Depending on its source and the geological conditions it passes through, water absorbs different minerals. This is why every natural mineral water has its own unique mineral composition.
In my comparison, the values vary widely:
EIRA Sparkling: 36 mg/l
MonViso Canvas Still: 433 mg/l
The value of MonViso Canvas is about twelve times higher than that of EIRA Sparkling. However, this does not automatically mean that one water is better than the other. Most importantly, it means that the two waters have significantly different mineral compositions.
A direct comparison: What minerals are in the water?
It becomes particularly interesting when we not only look at the total mineral content, but also compare the individual minerals.
The following table shows the published analysis values in milligrams per litre.
Minerals | EIRA Sparkling | MonViso Canvas Still |
Sodium | 1,9 mg/l | 1,2 mg/l |
Calcium | 1 mg/l | 83 mg/l |
Magnesium | 0,27 mg/l | 31 mg/l |
Potassium | 0,25 mg/l | 1 mg/l |
Sulphate | 0,01 mg/l | 179 mg/l |
Chloride | 1,9 mg/l | 0,7 mg/l |
Bicarbonat | <3 mg/l | 231 mg/l |
TDS | 36 mg/l | 433 mg/l |
The differences are particularly noticeable in terms of the levels of calcium, magnesium, sulphate and bicarbonate.
EIRA Sparkling, on the other hand, has a very low mineral content. Overall, the concentrations of minerals are very low.
MonViso Canvas contains significantly higher levels of calcium and magnesium. These minerals are responsible for the water’s characteristic mineral profile. The higher concentrations of hydrogen carbonate and sulphate also define its composition.
Can you actually taste the difference?
Yes, because the mineral composition affects the taste and texture of mineral water. So water isn’t simply flavourless. Depending on its composition, it can taste soft, light, neutral, mineral-rich, full-bodied, sour, bitter, salty or slightly sweet.
EIRA Sparkling combines a pure, soft and minimalist taste with fine, subtle effervescence. It offers crisp freshness on the palate and comes across as light and understated. The carbonation complements the minimalist flavour profile without overpowering it.
MonViso Canvas Still is pure, soft and elegant, with a delicate and balanced texture. Its harmonious mineral composition, particularly its calcium and magnesium content, gives it a pleasantly silky mouthfeel. This is complemented by a subtle natural sweetness. MonViso Canvas Still has a different mineral structure and character to EIRA.
Discover both mineral waters at SOMMCADEMY!
Want to experience the difference for yourself? EIRA and MonViso Canvas are both available in the SOMMCADEMY shop.
Compare the mineral content of these two waters and discover which one suits your personal taste and goes best with your meals.
Not all water is the same. Take a closer look — and, above all, taste them.
Watch the experiment in the video
A picture may be worth a thousand words, but a video really drives home the difference.
In this YouTube video, you can follow the water comparison step by step and see for yourself what happens when EIRA Sparkling and MonViso Canvas evaporate completely.
Watch the video to find out why not all water is the same!
With that said: Drink water, #stayhydrated
Best regards
Timo Bausch
Certified Water Sommelier
About SOMMCADEMY
Water is more than just a basic necessity. It represents taste, health, and experience. A new awareness is emerging: Drinking mindfully, recognizing differences, and truly understanding quality. As a certified Water Sommelier, I founded SOMMCADEMY to share the diversity and unique characteristics of mineral water with the world. With SOMMCADEMY, you can experience water in a whole new way, as a sensory journey that will make your event truly special / Timo Bausch Founder of SOMMCADEMY
Experience water in a new way. Book your exclusive experience now in Dubai, Abu Dhabi, or anywhere in the world.




